Dr. Walter Kimbrough, President of Dillard University and my fraternity brother, wrote an opinion piece for the Los Angeles Times in response to Dr Dre’s donation to the University of Southern California. Dr. Kimbrough loudly and clearly asks – why didn’t you donate your money to a black college? I do remember wondering for a second, why Dre chose USC in particular for his donation as opposed to the many other schools he could choose from including an HBCU. As I read various articles about Dre and Jimmy’s venture to create their own college program, the ingenuity and inspiration to create overtook any other questions for me. With the Creative Dreamer Award for ISU, we were able to pinpoint how we wanted our award to be distributed even down to what we wanted the scholarship selection committee to look like. I find it difficult to criticize Dre’s motivation and/or donation without having a better understanding of the stipulations tied to the donation. I would be interested in getting a clearer look at how the money is expected to be used for.
Check out my original post about Dr Dre’s donation here
None the less, Dr. Kimbrough’s unique position as a college president for a HBCU amplifies and adds credence to his argument. This man, entrusted to develop the students at one of the nation’s premier black institutions for higher education, delivers a clear and unapologetic argument to Dre and other minorities in power. Surely, if anyone understands how $35 million dollars would impact a HBCU, Dr. Kimbrough would. His call to Dre ,and what I hope is not lost, call to Black people all over is to invest in ourselves and programs that we feel have helped make us who we are. Questioning Dre is not where your involvement in this should begin and end. Yes, we can question and challenge the motives of our celebrities and politicians, but that doesnt stop you from getting up and getting involved either. Let’s make sure we’re living up to the same high expectations we’re asking others to abide by.
Personally, I don’t feel I can question where Dre donates his money. The Jimmy Iovine and Andre Young Academy for Arts, Technology and the Business of Innovation still sounds like an amazing opportunity to influence young adults and create stimulating learning experiences for all those involved. Would $35 million have been useful at an HBCU? Of course! But your $200 will be equally as useful at your high school, college, church, etc… Think of a program that has truly influenced who you are today. Think of a way you can give back to the people who currently use the program. Better yet persuade your family and friends to give back to the organization as well.
By Walter M. Kimbrough
May 21, 2013
I was in Detroit preparing to give a speech last week when the news came across my Twitter feed: “Dr. Dre and music producer Jimmy Iovine donate $70 million to USC to create new degree.” As one of the first university presidents from the hip-hop generation, I had to stop and read the story immediately.
The two music moguls and co-founders of Beats Electronics — recognizing that they needed a new type of creative talent for their growing music technology business — are funding a four-year program that blends liberal arts, graphic and product design, business and technology.
I understood their need to build a pool of skilled talent. But why at USC? Iovine’s daughter is an alum, sure. And he just gave its commencement address. Andre Young — before he was Dr. Dre — grew up in nearby Compton, where he rose to fame as part of the rap group N.W.A. The Beats headquarters are on L.A.’s Westside.
Still, what if Dre had given $35 million — his half of the USC gift and about 10% of his wealth, according to a Forbes estimate — to an institution that enrolls the very people who supported his career from the beginning? An institution where the majority of students are low-income? A place where $35 million would represent a truly transformational gift?
Why didn’t Dr. Dre give it to a black college?
Make no mistake: This donation is historic. It appears to be the largest gift by a black man to any college or university, comparable to the gift Bill Cosby and his wife, Camille, gave toSpelman College in 1988. Some 25 years later, their $20-million gift (about $39 million in inflation-adjusted dollars) is still the largest-ever private gift to a historically black college. Dre gave USC almost triple the amount Oprah Winfrey has given Morehouse College over the years. Sean “Diddy” Combs gave $500,000 to Howard University in 1999, which he attended before launching a successful career.
A hip-hop icon is now the new black higher-ed philanthropy king. We’ve never seen a donation to rival this from any black celebrity — musician, athlete or actor — and that fact must be celebrated.
But as the president of a black college, it pains me as well. I can’t help but wish that Dre’s wealth, generated as it was by his largely black hip-hop fans, was coming back to support that community.
USC is a great institution, no question. But it has a $3.5-billion endowment, the 21st largest in the nation and much more than every black college — combined. Less than 20% of USC’s student body qualifies for federal Pell Grants, given to students from low-income families, compared with two-thirds of those enrolled at black colleges. USC has also seen a steady decrease in black student enrollment, which is now below 5%.
A new report on black male athletes and racial inequities shows that only 2.2% of USC undergrads are black men, compared with 56% of its football and basketball teams, one of the largest disparities in the nation. And given USC’s $45,602 tuition next year, I’m confident Dre could have sponsored multiple full-ride scholarships to private black colleges for the cost of one at USC.
Maybe some suspect that a historically black college or university would not have the breadth or depth of expertise on its faculty to spearhead an innovative academy. Nothing could be further from the truth.
This future Jimmy Iovine and Andre Young Academy for Arts, Technology and the Business of Innovation is to be multidisciplinary, with a technology focus. In 2011, the National Science Foundation noted that black colleges are a major source of scientists and engineers. In fact, the top five producers of blacks who go on to earn science, technology, engineering and math graduate degrees are black colleges, as are 20 of the top 50. Once you add in the musical legacy of black colleges’ choirs and marching bands, they are the perfect locations for an academy like this.
In the end, though, this is his money, and endowing a program geographically nearby, where he can have ongoing input and contact, makes sense. I do hope it will recruit and enroll a diverse class of students and not become some enclave for the already privileged student body there.
But more important, I hope this groundbreaking gift inspires other celebrities and musical artists to make similar donations to higher education. And that they will consider doing it in a manner that will be truly transformative. This gift is gravy for USC; for a black college, it would transform not just individuals but whole institutions and communities.
In the Detroit airport on my way home, I counted seven people sporting the stylish Beats by Dre headphones on the way to my gate. All seven were black men, like me. My own Dre earbuds were in my briefcase. I’m sure we all bought them not only to support Dr. Dre but because of the quality of the product.
My challenge is to figure out how to get Dr. Dre and others to listen as well, because when they support black colleges, they are also supporting a quality product.
Walter M. Kimbrough is the president of Dillard University, a liberal arts black college in New Orleans.
Check out a spotlight featured on The Grio about Dr. Walter Kimbrough for more information about his background and role as an educator.